Old vs. New: which Amps and Pedals sound better?
Does new always sound better?
2,1 / 5,0 | 
Do modern amps and pedals always sound better than older versions? Or are we fooling ourselves? Food for thought.
Amps and Pedals: Our opinion
As a guitarist, you might know this feeling all too well. You’re in a music store or browsing online, and some new effect pedals or amps catch your eye. It’s easy to think this new gear could be the missing piece to your perfect sound. But is new really always better? Or do our ears just always crave new sounds?
Innovation vs. Tradition
The advantages of modern technology:
Modern stereo effects pedals and amplifiers often have digital tech built in that lets them produce a wide range of sounds and do lots of different things. Thanks to better components, these devices are often more versatile, have more settings and presets, and are also more durable and robust. This versatility can be a great advantage, especially for guitarists who like to experiment.
The appeal of traditional devices:
Many guitarists love the classic sound of old amps and pedals. The sound of these devices is often considered warmer and more authentic. They are also often easier to use and have aesthetic and historical value. These devices’ vintage charm and unique sound character are irreplaceable for many musicians.
Better or just different?
What does “better” evem mean?
What’s “better” is often down to personal taste. New effects amps and pedals can be great in one context but less suitable in another.
The fallacy of the ‘new’:
Isn’t it just human nature to think that new is always better? New devices typically have different sonic characteristics and more functions, but that doesn’t necessarily mean they’re better. We’re often tempted to underestimate our proven “old” devices when faced with something new and unknown.
It’s pretty common for manufacturers to release new versions of their classic products. Usually, it’s just because they’ve added more features or made some improvements. They’re also producing many of the older components more efficiently. The new versions are designed to be as close as possible to the original specs, but any change can affect the sound. The question is whether the sound is really better and whether the new version is an improvement.
Practical considerations: Choosing pedals and amps
- How do I choose the right amps and pedals?
- Testing: It’s crucial to test new equipment in person. This is the only way to determine whether it meets your expectations.
- Combining: Sometimes, combining old and new equipment can create interesting and unique sounds.
- Research: Read reviews and recommendations for pedals and amps, for example, here at Gearnews and from other guitarists, to make an informed decision.
- Keep an eye on your budget:
- Value for money: The most expensive devices are not always the best. Often, older models offer better value for your money.
- Second-hand market: You can often find high-quality devices at a fraction of the original price on the second-hand market in forums and other places.
Conclusion and personal experience
Something similar happened to me recently: I took an “old” pedal out of a drawer I’ve had for years and used to play with regularly. In this case, it was an MXR GT-OD overdrive pedal*. It had been in my drawer, all jumbled up, lonely, and forgotten. I tried it out at the next rehearsal, and it was great!
I don’t know why I got rid of the pedal back then and put it away. I probably found something I liked better and forgot about it. I’ll leave it on my pedal board for now until I find something new that I like less.
When it comes to effects pedals and amps, there’s no one-size-fits-all “better.” Every guitarist has to figure out what gear works best for their playing style and sound ideas. New technologies offer some amazing possibilities, but old classics have their own charm.
Ultimately, what matters is that you are happy with your equipment and create your unique sound. Experiment, combine, and find your own sound, regardless of whether your equipment is brand new, digital, or vintage.
Please feel free to let to us know in the comments below if you’ve had similar experiences and what you think about the topic.
Originally published at Gearnews.de by Andreas Cordes, translation by Julian Schmauch.
*This post contains affiliate links and/or widgets. When you buy a product via our affiliate partner, we receive a small commission that helps support what we do. Don’t worry, you pay the same price. Thanks for your support!
This might also interest you
